Chuck Holton
Politics • Culture • News
Ceasefire or Smokescreen? The Truth Behind Israel's "Truce" with Hezbollah
November 27, 2024
post photo preview

If you’ve been tuning into mainstream news, you might believe a historic ceasefire has brought peace to the conflict between Israel and Hezbollah. The truth, however, is far more complicated—and far less promising. What’s being heralded as a ceasefire is actually a shaky, one-sided truce, and Hezbollah isn’t even part of the deal. Let’s break down what’s really happening.

What’s Actually Happening?

At its core, this is a 60-day truce involving Israel, the United States, UNIFIL, and the Lebanese government. Notice anyone missing? That’s right—Hezbollah. Despite the fanfare, Hezbollah hasn’t agreed to stop fighting. In fact, they’ve spent the last 48 hours firing over 500 rockets, missiles, and drones into Israel, all while Israel pounds their positions across Lebanon in a pre-truce blitz.

The agreement stipulates that the Lebanese Army will move into southern Lebanon, policing the area south of the Litani River to prevent Hezbollah attacks. But here’s the catch: Hezbollah essentially is the Lebanese Army, or at least half of it. Entrusting them to dismantle Hezbollah’s military infrastructure is like asking a fox to guard the henhouse.

Israel’s Terms

Despite its limitations, the deal isn’t a total loss for Israel. Here’s what they gained:

  1. Freedom to Strike: Israel retains the right to respond to threats in Lebanon without prior U.S. approval. While they’ve agreed to alert the U.S. “whenever possible,” they can act unilaterally if needed. This flexibility allows Israel to neutralize immediate threats, such as missile launchers or incoming weapon shipments from Iran.

  2. Continued Surveillance: Israel can keep flying reconnaissance missions over Lebanon, albeit with a promise to avoid sonic booms over Beirut—an intimidation tactic they’ve frequently employed.

  3. Disruption of Iranian Supply Lines: The U.S. committed to helping Israel curb Iran’s weapon shipments into Lebanon, even suggesting American involvement in targeting smuggling routes.

On paper, this gives Israel room to breathe and regroup without sacrificing its security. But the big question remains: will Hezbollah abide by the truce?

Hezbollah’s Reality

Hezbollah is hurting—badly. Over the past few months, Israel has devastated their infrastructure:

  • 80% of Hezbollah’s rockets and missiles have been destroyed or fired.

  • Their command structure has been decimated, with thousands of operatives killed.

  • Entire villages in southern Lebanon, once Hezbollah strongholds, are now ghost towns.

Even Iran, Hezbollah’s main backer, is reportedly urging them to seek a ceasefire. The financial and military toll has been enormous, and Hezbollah’s paranoia is at an all-time high. They’ve allegedly detained—or even executed—over 200 operatives on suspicion of collaborating with Israel.

Why Did Israel Agree to a Truce?

Critics within Israel argue that this is a missed opportunity to finish the job. With Hezbollah on the ropes, some believe Israel should push harder to dismantle them completely, much like its declared goal of eradicating Hamas in Gaza. However, there are strategic reasons behind Israel’s decision:

  1. Focusing Resources: By pausing the northern conflict, Israel can concentrate on Gaza, the West Bank, and its growing standoff with Iran.

  2. Protecting Civilians: Over 60,000 Israelis displaced from their homes in the north could begin returning under the truce’s protection.

  3. International Optics: This deal provides Israel with political capital. If Hezbollah breaks the truce, it exposes their aggression, giving Israel a stronger justification to escalate again.

The U.S. Role

The Biden administration is already taking a victory lap, touting this truce as a diplomatic triumph. But let’s be clear: the U.S. isn’t a neutral player here. By brokering a deal that leans heavily on Israel’s concessions while ignoring Hezbollah’s non-participation, the U.S. appears more concerned with optics than with lasting peace.

And then there’s UNIFIL, the UN peacekeeping force tasked with monitoring southern Lebanon. Historically, UNIFIL has been criticized for its pro-Palestinian bias, raising doubts about its ability—or willingness—to ensure Hezbollah complies. Meanwhile, the U.S. continues funneling hundreds of millions of dollars to the UN despite its consistent failures in conflict zones.

What Happens Next?

This truce is a gamble. If Hezbollah abides, it could signal their desperation and allow Israel to regroup. But if they exploit the situation—using the Litani River as a shield for continued attacks—Israel will have no choice but to resume hostilities. Either way, this conflict is far from over.

For now, the people of northern Israel can hope for a reprieve. But as history has shown, hope isn’t a strategy. And in this region, peace is rarely more than an illusion.

 

community logo
Join the Chuck Holton Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
11
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
Bondi Beach Massacre

Here's a longer version of the videio I showed on today's live:

00:10:42
Want to See What Combat is Like?

Several infantrymen from the Azov battalion clearing houses near Toretsk. Witness the utter destruction, and the horrific conditions created by this war. Warning: Foul language is used (in Ukrainian with subtitles)

00:12:51
September 18, 2025
Benjamin Netanyahu Explains the Israeli Economy

Netanyahu was once Israeli Finance Minister - and it shows. He understands a lot about economics, and is worth listening to in order to get a sense for where Israel's economy is headed.

00:08:49
Episode 622 - Field Producer Dennis Azato and Chuck Reminisce

My erstwhile field producer and cameraman Dennis Azato has accompanied me on ten years of adventures across the globe. Today he joins me in Ukraine and we spend some time remembering our many trips together.

Episode 622 - Field Producer Dennis Azato and Chuck Reminisce
$5 A Month Locals Membership

Sign up for Locals now through January 4th and pay only $5 a month for the entire year. That’s $4 off every month and $48 in total savings. Enjoy ad-free content, behind-the-scenes access, and live calls where you can connect directly with Chuck. This also makes a great Christmas gift.

https://chuckholton.locals.com/support/promo/CHRISTMAS2026

post photo preview

Look who I was so privileged to listen to and meet at the “Israel, You’re Not Alone” conference last Sunday!
Doron Keidar is here in the U.S. speaking to & training our government/military on what he has learned as a Special Forces Commander in the IDF these past two horrific years. His message to us was powerful! “Be ready, they’re coming here for us!” As a bonus, Joshua Aaron (American-Israeli musician) closed the conference with an hour of worship in English and Hebrew!

post photo preview
Three Americans Killed in Syria — and the Question Washington Doesn’t Want to Answer

Breaking news this Saturday: three Americans are dead in Syria tonight, three more are wounded, and the attack—described by U.S. Central Command as an ambush carried out by a lone ISIS gunman—has once again dragged the Syrian war back into the American consciousness for a few brief hours, which is usually all the time the public gives it before the news cycle moves on and the families are left to carry the weight alone.

 

CENTCOM says two of the dead were U.S. service members and one was an American civilian contractor, and that the attacker was engaged and killed as well, with names being withheld until next of kin are notified, which is the right thing to do; but even with those official facts in hand, I want to slow the pace down a little bit and do what I always try to do here—put this in context—because in a place like Syria, the story you get in the headline is almost never the story that explains why this happened.

I’m not interested in reporting tragedy like it’s a scoreboard, and I’m not interested in repeating a paragraph of breaking news without the background that makes it intelligible; I spent eight years in the military, and I’ve spent more than twenty years following the U.S. military across the globe—Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria included, with more than a dozen trips into Afghanistan, roughly fifteen into Iraq, and seven or so into Syria—so when Americans die in a place most people couldn’t find on a map, I feel a responsibility to show you what the map actually means.

The desert isn’t empty—ISIS hides in the “nothing”

The reported location of the attack is Palmyra—Palmira on some maps—an ancient city in central Syria that sits on the edge of a brutal expanse of desert, the kind of wide open, sun-blasted country where outsiders assume nothing lives and nothing happens, when in reality it’s exactly the kind of terrain insurgents love because “nothing” is a perfect disguise, a perfect place to move, cache weapons, blend into small villages, disappear into wadis, and wait for opportunities.

Palmyra also sits inside territory controlled by Syria’s new administration under Ahmed al-Sharaa, and if that name makes you pause, it should, because this is where Syrian politics gets complicated in the way only Syria can do: al-Sharaa rose through jihadist ranks, he has a history tied to insurgent warfare against Americans in Iraq, he was captured and held for years, and he later returned to Syria and consolidated power with strong Turkish backing—so when you hear phrases like “new Syrian administration” or “transitional government,” don’t imagine a Western-style democracy that suddenly appeared out of the sand; imagine a patchwork of militias, alliances of convenience, old enemies wearing new uniforms, and a leadership class that wants international legitimacy while carrying a past that cannot be scrubbed clean with a new suit and a new flag.

Now layer on top of that the reality that ISIS is not gone from Syria, not even close.

U.S. estimates have long suggested there are still roughly 2,000 to 3,000 ISIS fighters operating in and around the central Syrian desert, and there are far more than that if you include facilitators, family networks, financiers, and the enormous number of ISIS-linked detainees and relatives held in camps and makeshift prisons; and while that fight has mostly slipped out of the American public’s view, it continues quietly, relentlessly, week after week, because the moment pressure is relieved in a place like this, the violence doesn’t fade—it regroups.

Why American troops are still there—despite everything

The United States currently has about 900 troops in Syria, a number that matters because it tells you how thin the margin is between “containment” and “collapse,” especially when the enemy has deep local roots and decades of practice living off the land and off the grievances of the people around them; and those American troops are there for one primary purpose: to keep a lid on ISIS so we don’t wake up one day to another wave of mass executions, terror-state governance, and regional destabilization that forces the world back into a far more expensive war.

That’s the mission, and it’s not abstract; when ISIS surged the last time, the human cost was staggering, and it wasn’t paid by politicians or pundits—it was paid by Iraqi soldiers, Kurdish fighters, civilians, and yes, Americans too—and the reason our presence in Syria still functions as a deterrent is that in a powder keg region, a small, capable American footprint has a way of discouraging ambitious actors from taking the final step that turns instability into open war.

But here is the part that doesn’t get said out loud very often: the mission in Syria is increasingly tangled up in partnerships that are, at best, uneasy and, at worst, morally and strategically risky.

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
The Dark Fleet Is Fueling the World’s Dictators — And the U.S. Might Finally Be Ready to Do Something About It

I’m coming to you today from Panama, where I’ve been digging into a story that’s far bigger than most people realize. It involves a shadowy network of ships—1,423 of them at last count—that roam the world’s oceans moving sanctioned oil for regimes like Russia, Iran, and Venezuela. Some call it the dark fleet, others the ghost fleet, but whatever the name, it’s become a lifeline for the world’s worst dictators.

Out of those 1,423 vessels, roughly 920 are sanctioned themselves. These aren’t just ships doing business in a gray area—they are part of a global ecosystem of deception, fraud, and corruption that props up authoritarian governments and undermines the international rules that keep maritime trade safe. They spoof GPS signals, turn off their transponders, swap oil with “cleaner” tankers in the dead of night, operate under shell-company ownership, and sail uninsured—floating environmental disasters just waiting to happen.

And for years, not much was done about it. But that may be changing.

Just days ago, the United States seized a massive VLCC tanker—the Skipper—carrying 1.8 million barrels of Venezuelan crude bound for Cuba. It’s a move that seems small on its own, but it hints at something larger: Washington may finally be realizing that targeting the dark fleet isn’t just desirable—it’s strategically powerful.

That raises a fascinating question: What would happen if the U.S. and its allies cracked down hard on these ghost ships—everywhere, all at once? Could it reshape global power? Could it even topple Maduro?

Let’s dig into that.

 

A Sanctions Loophole Big Enough to Sail a Tanker Through

These ghost ships function by exploiting cracks in the global maritime system. They manipulate AIS beacons, swap oil mid-ocean, hide ownership behind layers of shell companies, fly false flags, and operate without legitimate insurance. The UN’s maritime regulator has warned that these rusted, poorly maintained hulks are ticking time bombs—and we’ve already seen “Ukrainian sanctions” in action when Ukrainian sea drones blew up several shadow-fleet tankers in the Black Sea.

Imagine what happens if one of these decrepit tankers explodes in a global choke point like the Strait of Hormuz. You’d see a shock to oil markets overnight.

And yet, that’s the system that keeps Venezuela, Iran, and Russia afloat.

 

The U.S. Begins to Apply Pressure

The seizure of the Skipper wasn’t random. It’s part of a broader pressure campaign—one that former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has openly supported. He said plainly that going after these vessels is a direct way to choke off the revenue Maduro depends on to stay in power.

Pompeo also noted something key: Maduro’s regime probably has “weeks, not months” of financial runway without this illicit revenue stream. And Cuba—already experiencing rolling blackouts—relies on Venezuela for about a quarter of its total energy supply. This single tanker seizure hurts Havana even more than Caracas.

But perhaps the most important variable is geography. Satellite data reveals dozens of sanctioned tankers parked just off Venezuela’s northern coast. In theory, if the U.S. waits for them to exit Venezuela’s 200-mile EEZ, it could legally seize many of them—especially the stateless ones.

Imagine the U.S. grabbing one tanker per day.

The ripple effects would be enormous.

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Russia's Psychological Warfare Against Ukraine Escalates in 2025

I went to Ukraine to see if Ukraine is crumbling under the pressure from Russia or if they are holding their own. The people on the frontline suffer from drones attacking civilians and missiles striking every day, and the people want an end to the war that won't end with them under the rule of Russia. Because if that happens, the Ukrainians will be wiped out completely. 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals