Chuck Holton
News • Politics • Culture
Chuck Holton is an American war correspondent, published author, and motivational speaker.
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
Tonight: Answering Idiots on Israel

I'll be talking about Scott Ritter's new interview out today in which he claims that Israel has lost the war and "its economy is in tatters." Here is the real truth of the matter:

The Economic Impact of War: Israel vs. US in 2024

As Israel navigates the economic challenges of wartime, comparing its financial standing with a non-wartime economy like the United States offers valuable insights into Israel's resilience and the broader implications of conflict on national finances.

Economic Growth: Slowing but Steady

Despite the ongoing conflict in Gaza, Israel's economy is showing remarkable resilience. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) projects Israel's growth at 1.6% for 2024, down from 2% in 2023. While this represents a slowdown, it's noteworthy that the economy continues to expand under challenging circumstances.

In contrast, the US economy, free from direct military conflicts on its soil, is expected to grow at 2.1% in 2024. This slight edge in growth demonstrates the economic drag of war, but also highlights Israel's ability to maintain positive growth despite adversity.

Government Spending and Deficits

The war has inevitably led to increased government spending in Israel. The fiscal deficit is projected to rise to about 6% on average from 2023-2025, up significantly from previous estimates. This increase reflects the immediate costs of military operations and domestic support measures.

The US, while not at war, also runs a substantial deficit, projected at 5.3% of GDP for fiscal year 2024. This comparison shows that even in peacetime, major economies often operate with significant budget gaps.

Debt Levels: A Key Differentiator

One of Israel's economic strengths is its relatively low public debt, standing at about 67% of GDP. This is slightly below the average for OECD countries and provides Israel with financial flexibility during these challenging times.

The US, on the other hand, carries a much heavier debt burden, at approximately 123% of GDP. This stark difference underscores Israel's prudent pre-war financial management, which now serves as a buffer against economic shocks.

The Power of Reserves

Israel's substantial foreign exchange reserves, exceeding $200 billion, have proved crucial during this period. The Bank of Israel's decision to release $30 billion to support the currency demonstrates the strategic importance of these reserves. This move has helped maintain currency stability, a critical factor for economic confidence during wartime.

The US, given its unique position as the issuer of the world's primary reserve currency, doesn't maintain foreign exchange reserves in the same way. Instead, it relies on the inherent strength and global demand for the US dollar.

Concluding Thoughts

Israel's economy, while undoubtedly affected by the ongoing conflict, shows remarkable resilience. The country's strong fiscal position before the war, characterized by manageable debt and substantial reserves, has provided a crucial buffer against economic shocks.

When compared to the US, Israel's economy naturally shows signs of war-related stress, particularly in terms of slower growth and increased deficit spending. However, its lower debt levels and strategic use of reserves demonstrate effective economic management in challenging times.

As the situation evolves, Israel's economic performance will remain a testament to the importance of sound financial planning and the resilience of a diversified, modern economy in the face of geopolitical challenges.

To compare Israel's financial state to the US, let's examine the key economic indicators mentioned:

Economic Growth

• Israel: Expected to grow by 1.6% in 2024, down from 2% in 2023.
• US: The IMF projects US growth at 2.1% for 2024, slightly higher than Israel's forecast.

Fiscal Deficit

• Israel: Projected to increase to about 6% on average in 2023-25.
• US: The Congressional Budget Office projects a federal budget deficit of 5.3% of GDP for fiscal year 2024.

Public Debt

• Israel: About 67% of GDP.
• US: The US public debt is significantly higher, at approximately 123% of GDP.

Foreign Exchange Reserves

• Israel: More than $200 billion, with $30 billion released to support the currency.
• US: As the world's reserve currency, the US doesn't maintain foreign exchange reserves in the same way. Instead, it has gold reserves worth about $11 billion.

Comparative Analysis

1. Growth: While both countries are experiencing slower growth, the US is projected to outpace Israel slightly in 2024.

2. Fiscal Deficit: Israel's projected deficit is slightly higher than the US, indicating more fiscal pressure.

3. Public Debt: The US has a significantly higher public debt-to-GDP ratio, which could be a long-term concern.

4. Reserves: Israel's substantial foreign exchange reserves provide a strong buffer against economic shocks, especially relative to its size.

5. Economic Resilience: Despite the war's impact, Israel's economy shows resilience, maintaining stable growth and manageable debt levels.

6. Currency Stability: Israel's ability to support its currency with reserves demonstrates financial strength, while the US dollar's global reserve status provides inherent stability.

Overall, while Israel faces immediate challenges due to the conflict, its economic fundamentals remain relatively strong. The US, despite higher growth projections, faces long-term concerns with its significantly higher public debt.

Citations:
[1] https://www.iemed.org/publication/economic-impact-of-the-gaza-war/
[2] https://tradingeconomics.com/israel/gdp
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_history_of_Israel
[4] https://www.undp.org/sites/g/files/zskgke326/files/2024-05/2400257e-gaza_war-_expected_socioeconomic_impacts-pb.pdf
[5] https://www.cfr.org/article/us-aid-israel-four-charts
[6] https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20240605-israels-economy-is-creaking-under-the-effects-of-its-assault-on-gaza/
[7] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/as-israels-economy-struggles-leading-economists-say-ending-the-war-in-gaza-would-help
[8] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-68884729

Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
Ring Camera Video of Plane Crash

Here you can see the steep angle of the jet as it plummeted to earth - and looks like it was on fire.

00:00:12
Video From Philadelphia Plane Crash
00:00:12
Video of the Balboa Port

On the Pacific side of the Panama Canal near Panama City

00:00:09
Episode 622 - Field Producer Dennis Azato and Chuck Reminisce

My erstwhile field producer and cameraman Dennis Azato has accompanied me on ten years of adventures across the globe. Today he joins me in Ukraine and we spend some time remembering our many trips together.

Episode 622 - Field Producer Dennis Azato and Chuck Reminisce
ANOTHER Plane Crash

I'll go live in a bit with BREAKING news about another plane crash in the US.

When Panama Hosted President Xi

When the Chinese President last visited Panama, on December 2, 2018, I was there. They shut down the entire downtown area along the waterfront, closed the roads and hung Chinese flags along the route Xi's motorcade would travel. That was when then-President Varela signed on to the Belt and Road Initiative, becoming the first Latin American country to do so.

Part of the reason this happened is because the US basically turned its back on Panama after turning over the canal. Our lack of attention to this critical region left the door open for China to step through.

Now President Trump is (a bit clumsily, in my opinion) trying to reverse that. Keep this scenario in mind when you hear someone say we should leave Ukraine to its own devices or pull out of the middle east or have nothing to do with Armenia. If the US is not present, someone else will be, and that someone will certainly not have America's best interests in mind.

I will be in Panama city on Friday reporting on ...

February 01, 2025

WOW! At first you see the point of impact, and a burned building across the street, and it appears that they busted butt to clean up the wreckage...then you see how far back the actual damage really is. The restaurant right there at the scene has a perfectly clean parking lot, and then, what looks like a city block in the other direction...😧

post photo preview
America’s Hostages: Strength Is the Only Solution

 

Thousands of American citizens are held in foreign prisons, but only a small number are political hostages—used as bargaining chips by hostile regimes and terrorist organizations. According to the Foley Foundation, which tracks wrongful detentions, there are 46 American nationals currently unjustly imprisoned across 16 countries, with most held for over five years. The key to bringing them home lies in decisive leadership and a foreign policy that projects strength.

The Reality in Gaza

Recent hostage releases in Gaza highlight the stakes. Keith Siegel, a 65-year-old American-Israeli occupational therapist, was freed after 484 days in captivity. Hamas abducted him and his wife during the October 7, 2023, attack on Israel. His wife was released earlier, but Keith remained in captivity for over a year. Meanwhile, several other American citizens remain missing or confirmed dead, including Adon Alexander (21) and Nam Sagui Deen (35). Reports indicate at least seven American hostages have died in Hamas custody, further emphasizing the urgency of strong leadership.

Trump’s Diplomacy in Action: Venezuela Hostage Release

President Trump’s no-nonsense approach to hostage situations has already yielded results. His envoy was recently sent to Venezuela to secure the release of six American hostages held by the Maduro regime. These individuals had been detained under the Biden administration with little progress toward their release. However, Trump’s firm stance and direct diplomatic intervention led to a breakthrough, once again proving that adversaries only respond to strength.

Speaking the Only Language Hostile Actors Understand

History has shown that hostile governments and terrorist groups only respect force, not diplomacy filled with empty promises. A story from Iraq illustrates this well: when U.S. Army Rangers faced resistance in a hostile city, their commander warned the locals that any attack would be met with overwhelming force. The first time they were fired upon, they leveled the area, sending a clear message. From that point on, the Rangers patrolled without incident.

This is the exact approach America must take regarding hostage situations. The U.S. government should immediately and aggressively respond whenever an American is taken.

The Path Forward: Strength, Not Weakness

President Trump’s recent actions in Venezuela send a powerful message—hostage-taking will not be tolerated. This kind of deterrence is the only way to protect American citizens abroad. The U.S. must adopt an ironclad stance:

  • Immediate retaliation for wrongful detentions
  • Strong diplomatic pressure backed by military might
  • No appeasement, only action

Trump’s decisive moves contrast sharply with the Biden administration’s passive approach, which left many American hostages forgotten. The world’s bad actors are taking notice—when America speaks with strength and conviction, hostages come home.

The lesson is clear: if America wants to prevent future hostage crises, it must ensure that taking an American is a costly mistake for any regime or terrorist group.

Read full Article
post photo preview
U.S. Airstrikes Target ISIS Leaders in Somalia:
What It Means

 

The U.S. military, in coordination with Somali forces, just took out some key ISIS figures in Somalia’s Puntland region. If you haven’t been following the situation, here’s a quick breakdown of what happened and why it matters.

What Went Down?

Over the weekend, U.S. airstrikes hit ISIS positions in the Golis Mountains of northern Somalia. The Puntland government confirmed that these strikes "neutralized" senior ISIS leaders. While the details are still scarce, what we do know is that these operations are part of a broader campaign that Puntland’s security forces have been waging against ISIS since December.

U.S. President Donald Trump even chimed in on Truth Social, saying he personally ordered the strikes. Meanwhile, the Somali government in Mogadishu called the operation a joint effort with Washington, reinforcing their ongoing security partnership.

Why Does This Matter?

ISIS in Somalia is relatively small compared to the dominant Al-Qaeda-linked Al-Shabaab, but its presence has been growing, especially in Puntland. The group is believed to be under the control of Abdul Qadir Mumin, a Puntland native and one of the highest-ranking ISIS leaders still standing.

Mumin has dodged multiple U.S. airstrikes over the years, which, according to experts, gives him significant credibility within ISIS’s global network. Taking him or his top lieutenants out would be a major win for counterterrorism efforts in the region.

U.S. Involvement: A Game Changer?

The Puntland government was quick to call U.S. support “invaluable” in their fight against terrorism. Airstrikes like these not only take out key ISIS figures but also send a clear message that terrorist networks won’t be allowed to carve out safe havens.

For Somalia, it’s another step in securing its territory, especially in Puntland, which has been working hard to push extremists out of the Golis Mountains. And for the U.S., it reinforces Washington’s long-standing commitment to counterterrorism operations in Africa.

Photo I took in Mogadishu of Tribal gunmen we hired for secuirty

 

What’s Next?

While the airstrikes were successful, the fight against ISIS in Somalia isn’t over. The group still has operatives in the region, and as history has shown, eliminating leadership doesn’t always mean the end of a terrorist organization.

But one thing is clear: Puntland and its U.S. partners are ramping up their offensive, and ISIS’s days in Somalia may be numbered.

Stay tuned as more details come out.

Read full Article
post photo preview
China’s Growing Influence in Panama:
A Real Threat or Just Business?

 

The U.S. has been Panama’s biggest investor for decades, pouring billions into finance, logistics, tourism, and trade. But since 2017, when Panama cut ties with Taiwan and recognized Beijing, China has aggressively expanded its footprint—especially in infrastructure, ports, and major construction projects.

Why Does This Matter?
China’s investments aren’t just about business—they’re often tied to debt-trap diplomacy. This happens when China finances big projects in smaller countries, but under tough loan terms. If the country struggles to repay, China gains leverage—sometimes even control over key assets. This has happened in other nations, where China has taken over ports, railways, or critical infrastructure when debts weren’t paid.

Panama’s Position
Right now, the U.S. still leads in total foreign direct investment (FDI)—meaning American businesses have put more long-term money into Panama than China has. But China’s influence is growing fast. It’s not just about money; it’s about strategic control. If Panama takes on too much Chinese-backed debt, it could find itself economically dependent on Beijing—risking sovereignty over its own key industries.

Bottom Line

For now, the U.S. remains Panama’s top investor, but China is playing the long game. The question is: Will Panama benefit from Chinese money, or will it find itself trapped in a costly deal it can’t escape?

Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals