Chuck Holton
Politics • Culture • News
Ceasefire or Smokescreen? The Truth Behind Israel's "Truce" with Hezbollah
November 27, 2024
post photo preview

If you’ve been tuning into mainstream news, you might believe a historic ceasefire has brought peace to the conflict between Israel and Hezbollah. The truth, however, is far more complicated—and far less promising. What’s being heralded as a ceasefire is actually a shaky, one-sided truce, and Hezbollah isn’t even part of the deal. Let’s break down what’s really happening.

What’s Actually Happening?

At its core, this is a 60-day truce involving Israel, the United States, UNIFIL, and the Lebanese government. Notice anyone missing? That’s right—Hezbollah. Despite the fanfare, Hezbollah hasn’t agreed to stop fighting. In fact, they’ve spent the last 48 hours firing over 500 rockets, missiles, and drones into Israel, all while Israel pounds their positions across Lebanon in a pre-truce blitz.

The agreement stipulates that the Lebanese Army will move into southern Lebanon, policing the area south of the Litani River to prevent Hezbollah attacks. But here’s the catch: Hezbollah essentially is the Lebanese Army, or at least half of it. Entrusting them to dismantle Hezbollah’s military infrastructure is like asking a fox to guard the henhouse.

Israel’s Terms

Despite its limitations, the deal isn’t a total loss for Israel. Here’s what they gained:

  1. Freedom to Strike: Israel retains the right to respond to threats in Lebanon without prior U.S. approval. While they’ve agreed to alert the U.S. “whenever possible,” they can act unilaterally if needed. This flexibility allows Israel to neutralize immediate threats, such as missile launchers or incoming weapon shipments from Iran.

  2. Continued Surveillance: Israel can keep flying reconnaissance missions over Lebanon, albeit with a promise to avoid sonic booms over Beirut—an intimidation tactic they’ve frequently employed.

  3. Disruption of Iranian Supply Lines: The U.S. committed to helping Israel curb Iran’s weapon shipments into Lebanon, even suggesting American involvement in targeting smuggling routes.

On paper, this gives Israel room to breathe and regroup without sacrificing its security. But the big question remains: will Hezbollah abide by the truce?

Hezbollah’s Reality

Hezbollah is hurting—badly. Over the past few months, Israel has devastated their infrastructure:

  • 80% of Hezbollah’s rockets and missiles have been destroyed or fired.

  • Their command structure has been decimated, with thousands of operatives killed.

  • Entire villages in southern Lebanon, once Hezbollah strongholds, are now ghost towns.

Even Iran, Hezbollah’s main backer, is reportedly urging them to seek a ceasefire. The financial and military toll has been enormous, and Hezbollah’s paranoia is at an all-time high. They’ve allegedly detained—or even executed—over 200 operatives on suspicion of collaborating with Israel.

Why Did Israel Agree to a Truce?

Critics within Israel argue that this is a missed opportunity to finish the job. With Hezbollah on the ropes, some believe Israel should push harder to dismantle them completely, much like its declared goal of eradicating Hamas in Gaza. However, there are strategic reasons behind Israel’s decision:

  1. Focusing Resources: By pausing the northern conflict, Israel can concentrate on Gaza, the West Bank, and its growing standoff with Iran.

  2. Protecting Civilians: Over 60,000 Israelis displaced from their homes in the north could begin returning under the truce’s protection.

  3. International Optics: This deal provides Israel with political capital. If Hezbollah breaks the truce, it exposes their aggression, giving Israel a stronger justification to escalate again.

The U.S. Role

The Biden administration is already taking a victory lap, touting this truce as a diplomatic triumph. But let’s be clear: the U.S. isn’t a neutral player here. By brokering a deal that leans heavily on Israel’s concessions while ignoring Hezbollah’s non-participation, the U.S. appears more concerned with optics than with lasting peace.

And then there’s UNIFIL, the UN peacekeeping force tasked with monitoring southern Lebanon. Historically, UNIFIL has been criticized for its pro-Palestinian bias, raising doubts about its ability—or willingness—to ensure Hezbollah complies. Meanwhile, the U.S. continues funneling hundreds of millions of dollars to the UN despite its consistent failures in conflict zones.

What Happens Next?

This truce is a gamble. If Hezbollah abides, it could signal their desperation and allow Israel to regroup. But if they exploit the situation—using the Litani River as a shield for continued attacks—Israel will have no choice but to resume hostilities. Either way, this conflict is far from over.

For now, the people of northern Israel can hope for a reprieve. But as history has shown, hope isn’t a strategy. And in this region, peace is rarely more than an illusion.

 

community logo
Join the Chuck Holton Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
11
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
Watch: Biblical Red Heifer ritual comes to life

in a rehearsal ceremony, A red heifer raised in Israel was disqualified for sacrifice after two black hairs were found on its body. It was used in a practice burning ceremony for priests.

00:00:05
Pray for Texas Flood Victims

Wow.

00:00:30
Free Burma Rangers Under Fire

WARNING: This video contains graphic material.
The Free Burma Rangers charged into the line of fire to extract the wounded from the frontlines in Burma during the ongoing war for freedom.
One of their own, Ranger Benedict To, was killed in the line of duty as he worked to get those who were wounded out of harms way.

00:07:03
Episode 622 - Field Producer Dennis Azato and Chuck Reminisce

My erstwhile field producer and cameraman Dennis Azato has accompanied me on ten years of adventures across the globe. Today he joins me in Ukraine and we spend some time remembering our many trips together.

Episode 622 - Field Producer Dennis Azato and Chuck Reminisce
Travel to Armenia with Chuck Holton

Join us for an unforgettable 10-day adventure through Armenia. Explore ancient Christian sites, breathtaking mountains, and the resilient spirit of the Armenian people, guided by Chuck Holton and his family. Perfect for couples, Christian adventurers, photographers & drone lovers. $2700 per person – limited spots available! Link to application and details here, https://www.holtonnews.com/armenia-tour/

post photo preview
Looking to Adopt?

Two sweet dogs were left on Chuck’s property and we’re hoping to find them a loving home. They’re both friendly and healthy—the black one is a sweet little female and the brown one is a gentle male.

If you’re on the East Coast or near southern West Virginia and would like to adopt them, please email [email protected] to coordinate pickup.

Let’s find these two a good home.

post photo preview
The national library of Israel

A hot zone viewer named Rachael works at the national library of Israel and invited me for a tour today. Fascinating! Thank you, Rachel!

post photo preview
Blood Sea:
 Why the Houthis Just Sank Two Ships

 

This week, the Houthis took their war to a whole new level—sinking two commercial ships in the Red Sea in just a matter of days. First, the Magic Seas was hit and went down. Then came the Eternity C, boarded by armed Houthi fighters who planted explosives on the hull and detonated them. The shocking video released by the group shows militants moving through the ship, firing weapons into walls and windows. Most of the crew is still unaccounted for.

So why now?

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Ceasefire Illusions and the Battle for Real Peace in the Middle East

By Chuck Holton
Reporting from Jerusalem, Israel

Another Strike Looms: Israel Eyes Fordow, Again

As tensions simmer just beneath the surface in the Middle East, the illusion of ceasefires continues to dominate headlines. But from the ground here in Jerusalem, the reality is far different. Israel appears to be preparing for another potential strike on Iran—particularly the Fordow nuclear facility—amid concerns that time is running out to neutralize the threat of uranium enrichment. Israeli leadership is not waiting for diplomatic ceremonies. They’ve made it clear: the truce was conditional, and they reserve the right to act if Iran continues to endanger Israeli security.

That resolve was evident in Prime Minister Netanyahu’s recent visit to Washington, D.C., where he met twice with President Trump. Despite public speculation, it’s clear Netanyahu was not simply seeking peace talks. He emphasized the necessity of "finishing the job in Gaza" and praised America’s support—particularly the determination of U.S. B2 bomber pilots—as instrumental in reshaping the conflict.


Houthi Menace: Political Theater with Real Victims

Meanwhile, in a display of violence as propaganda, the Iranian-backed Houthis released another highly-produced video showing the sinking of commercial vessels like the Magic Seas—Greek-flagged, Liberian-registered, and completely unaffiliated with Israel. These attacks aren’t strategic; they’re sensational. Poorly trained operatives parading around as commandos show that the goal isn’t military victory but media relevance.

The real tragedy? Innocent seafarers becoming casualties in a conflict they never signed up for. And with every new attack, the narrative of peace grows thinner.


The Ceasefire Charade

Despite high-level efforts—most notably by President Trump—to broker ceasefires across the region, the facts on the ground reveal continued hostilities:

  • In Lebanon, Israeli forces are conducting daily drone strikes and eliminating Hezbollah leadership.

  • In Syria, IDF troops continue operations, targeting Iranian militias and weapons depots.

  • In Iran, mysterious explosions still rock military sites and infrastructure, hinting at covert operations.

  • In Gaza, heavy IDF activity persists as troops push deeper into urban strongholds like Beit Hanoun and Khan Yunis.

These are not signs of peace. These are signs of a nation that understands its survival depends on vigilance.


The Gaza Dilemma: Feeding the War Machine?

The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation has now distributed over 65 million meals to civilians in Gaza—funded in large part by U.S. taxpayers. But while the aid is vital for many, it raises a vital question: at what cost?

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Facts, Not Feelings

“Why Don’t You Talk About the Deaths in Gaza?”

That question came up—again. And here’s my answer: I do talk about it, just not in the way people want me to. If your side orchestrates an atrocity like October 7th, you don’t get to demand that the world ignore your consequences. Self-defense isn’t genocide.

Do civilians die in war? Of course—and every loss is tragic. But according to third-party data, the civilian-to-combatant ratio in Gaza is one of the lowest in modern warfare. Lower than in Iraq or Afghanistan. Lower than in Yemen. Lower even than Israel’s last major operations.

And no, Gaza isn’t being depopulated. In fact, population numbers show there are more people in Gaza today than at the war’s start. For a so-called genocide, that’s one remarkably inefficient campaign.


Crossing Borders and Cultures

Joining me in Israel is my good friend Oscar Blue Ramirez, who experienced firsthand what real border security looks like. After flying into Jordan, he spent over nine hours just trying to cross into Israel. From chaos on the Jordanian side to four-hour inspections on the Israeli end, Oscar came through sunburned, smoked out, and very much enlightened.

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals