Chuck Holton
Politics • Culture • News
Israel Confirms Identities of Four Slain Hostages Returned from Gaza
February 27, 2025
post photo preview

Israeli authorities have confirmed the identities of four hostages whose remains were returned from Gaza by Hamas. The victims—Itzik Elgarat, Ohad Yahalomi, Shlomo Mantzur, and Tsahi Idan—were among those abducted on October 7, 2023. Their return marks the final phase of a ceasefire deal initiated in January that saw 33 Israeli hostages returned, including both the living and deceased.

The Prime Minister’s Office stated that Yahalomi, Idan, and Elgarat were murdered while in captivity in Gaza, while Mantzur was killed during the initial attack and his body taken hostage. Their remains were identified by the National Forensic Medicine Center and Israeli police at the Abu Kabir Forensic Institute.

Despite their late-night arrival in Israel, citizens lined the roads along the transport route in a display of respect and mourning.

President Isaac Herzog expressed the nation’s grief, stating, “Israeli hearts ache upon receiving the bitter news,” while also emphasizing the moral obligation to bring back all remaining hostages.

Remembering the Victims

Ohad Yahalomi (50)

A resident of Kibbutz Nir Oz, Yahalomi was a devoted family man, passionate about sports and nature. A dual French-Israeli citizen, he worked for the Israel Nature and Parks Authority and co-authored a scorpion field guide. He was taken hostage on October 7 while defending his family, and his wife and daughters managed to escape. His son, Eitan, was also abducted but later released in November 2023.

Itzik Elgarat (68)

Also from Kibbutz Nir Oz, Elgarat was a well-loved community member known for his passion for soccer and backgammon. He served as a groundskeeper and maintenance worker, bringing warmth and laughter to his kibbutz. Initially reported as injured and alive in captivity, it was later revealed that he had died of starvation.

Tsahi Idan (49)

Kidnapped from Kibbutz Nahal Oz, Idan endured a horrific ordeal. His eldest daughter, Maayan, was shot and killed through the safe room door before he was dragged to Gaza. His abduction was live-streamed on Facebook by Hamas terrorists. Despite receiving signs of life from him in November 2023, his family was informed of his death before his remains were returned. He will be laid to rest beside his daughter.

Shlomo Mantzur (85)

A survivor of the Farhud pogrom in Iraq, Mantzur was one of the founders of Kibbutz Kissufim. A skilled carpenter and dedicated worker, he was abducted in his pajamas when terrorists stormed his home. His wife, Mazal, witnessed his capture. In early 2025, Israeli intelligence confirmed his death, and his remains were returned after 510 days in captivity.

The End of a Ceasefire Phase

The return of these four hostages marks the final exchange under the January ceasefire agreement, which secured the release of 33 hostages—25 alive and eight deceased. The Israeli government continues its efforts to secure the return of all hostages, reiterating that each case remains a humanitarian priority.

The sorrow of these families underscores the brutal impact of the October 7 attacks and the ongoing conflict. Their memory serves as a solemn reminder of Israel’s enduring struggle for security and justice.

community logo
Join the Chuck Holton Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
8
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
Join Our Next Live Call!

Thank you to everyone who joined our last live call. It’s always a highlight for me to hear from you, answer your questions, and give real-time updates on what’s happening around the world.

We do these calls every month for our Locals supporters, and it’s a great chance to connect directly, have real conversations, and go deeper into the stories that matter.

If you’d like to be part of the next one, we’ll be announcing the date soon, likely toward the end of this month. Hope to see you there.

01:41:03
Watch: Biblical Red Heifer ritual comes to life

in a rehearsal ceremony, A red heifer raised in Israel was disqualified for sacrifice after two black hairs were found on its body. It was used in a practice burning ceremony for priests.

00:00:05
Pray for Texas Flood Victims

Wow.

00:00:30
Episode 622 - Field Producer Dennis Azato and Chuck Reminisce

My erstwhile field producer and cameraman Dennis Azato has accompanied me on ten years of adventures across the globe. Today he joins me in Ukraine and we spend some time remembering our many trips together.

Episode 622 - Field Producer Dennis Azato and Chuck Reminisce
Attack Imminent?

Attack Imminent? Iran has abruptly closed its airspace, a known precursor to missile launches. At the same time, the Istanbul airport has cancelled all flights to Iran, Iraq, and Jordan - the flight path of a ballistic missile attack against Israel.

Both events come just hours after the IRGC announced that 'The Israeli attack against the Iranian President will not go unanswered.'

if an attack takes place I will go live as soon as I can

post photo preview
Looking to Adopt?

Two sweet dogs were left on Chuck’s property and we’re hoping to find them a loving home. They’re both friendly and healthy—the black one is a sweet little female and the brown one is a gentle male.

If you’re on the East Coast or near southern West Virginia and would like to adopt them, please email [email protected] to coordinate pickup.

Let’s find these two a good home.

post photo preview

Hi Chuck. I'd be interested in you covering Ukraine in the near future. I believe it is of great consequence prophetically - as we draw closer to the end of the (Church) age and Christ's second coming. I'll be praying for God's wisdom in all of your decision making. Thanks for your consideration!

A Report from Southern Israel

It was another blistering day down near the Gaza border — in more ways than one. As I stood on a familiar hilltop outside the town of Sderot, just two kilometers from the Gaza fence, the echoes of war were all around us. The dust clouds, the deep booms of airstrikes, the staccato of small arms fire — it’s not theoretical here. It’s live. And it’s real.

The View From the Front

Alongside my colleague Oscar Blue, I returned to the same overlook I’ve visited countless times since the war began. Today, we witnessed some of the most intense fighting to date. Just across the border in Beit Hanoun, Israeli Defense Forces are zeroing in on remaining pockets of Hamas resistance. Tanks and troop carriers moved back and forth, and jets screamed overhead. Israel is not letting up.

And yet, despite the active warzone just over the ridge, life in Israel continues. Families were out at pools and beaches enjoying Shabbat. Children played under the same skies where drones fly. This contrast is part of what makes Israel so remarkable. In the face of horror, life goes on. And buildings go up. The reconstruction in southern Israel is nothing short of miraculous. In Sderot and surrounding kibbutzim, new homes are rising, replacing those destroyed in the October 7th massacre.

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Blood Sea:
 Why the Houthis Just Sank Two Ships

 

This week, the Houthis took their war to a whole new level—sinking two commercial ships in the Red Sea in just a matter of days. First, the Magic Seas was hit and went down. Then came the Eternity C, boarded by armed Houthi fighters who planted explosives on the hull and detonated them. The shocking video released by the group shows militants moving through the ship, firing weapons into walls and windows. Most of the crew is still unaccounted for.

So why now?

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Ceasefire Illusions and the Battle for Real Peace in the Middle East

By Chuck Holton
Reporting from Jerusalem, Israel

Another Strike Looms: Israel Eyes Fordow, Again

As tensions simmer just beneath the surface in the Middle East, the illusion of ceasefires continues to dominate headlines. But from the ground here in Jerusalem, the reality is far different. Israel appears to be preparing for another potential strike on Iran—particularly the Fordow nuclear facility—amid concerns that time is running out to neutralize the threat of uranium enrichment. Israeli leadership is not waiting for diplomatic ceremonies. They’ve made it clear: the truce was conditional, and they reserve the right to act if Iran continues to endanger Israeli security.

That resolve was evident in Prime Minister Netanyahu’s recent visit to Washington, D.C., where he met twice with President Trump. Despite public speculation, it’s clear Netanyahu was not simply seeking peace talks. He emphasized the necessity of "finishing the job in Gaza" and praised America’s support—particularly the determination of U.S. B2 bomber pilots—as instrumental in reshaping the conflict.


Houthi Menace: Political Theater with Real Victims

Meanwhile, in a display of violence as propaganda, the Iranian-backed Houthis released another highly-produced video showing the sinking of commercial vessels like the Magic Seas—Greek-flagged, Liberian-registered, and completely unaffiliated with Israel. These attacks aren’t strategic; they’re sensational. Poorly trained operatives parading around as commandos show that the goal isn’t military victory but media relevance.

The real tragedy? Innocent seafarers becoming casualties in a conflict they never signed up for. And with every new attack, the narrative of peace grows thinner.


The Ceasefire Charade

Despite high-level efforts—most notably by President Trump—to broker ceasefires across the region, the facts on the ground reveal continued hostilities:

  • In Lebanon, Israeli forces are conducting daily drone strikes and eliminating Hezbollah leadership.

  • In Syria, IDF troops continue operations, targeting Iranian militias and weapons depots.

  • In Iran, mysterious explosions still rock military sites and infrastructure, hinting at covert operations.

  • In Gaza, heavy IDF activity persists as troops push deeper into urban strongholds like Beit Hanoun and Khan Yunis.

These are not signs of peace. These are signs of a nation that understands its survival depends on vigilance.


The Gaza Dilemma: Feeding the War Machine?

The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation has now distributed over 65 million meals to civilians in Gaza—funded in large part by U.S. taxpayers. But while the aid is vital for many, it raises a vital question: at what cost?

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals